We should not take part in it

( –

The following is a transcription of a private darśana given in Śrīla Gaura Govinda Svāmī Mahārāja’s hut after an initiation ceremony in Bhubaneswar, India, on 26 November, 1989, published in Ananda Sambada Newsletter Volume 4 Issue 1 February 2002

Devotee 1: You were talking about sādhu-nindā, an offence to a pure devotee as one of the offences to the holy name. Just for clarification, I wondered if this at all included neophyte devotees… if one is blasphemous towards a neophyte devotee, does this also have some effect on the holy name?
Śrīla Gaura Govinda Svāmī Mahārāja: Sādhu-nindā? Number one (offence)… ‘sādhu’ means he is a completely surrendered soul. He has completely dedicated his life to spreading the holy names throughout the world. He is a pure devotee. Do you understand? He is a sādhu.
Devotee 2: Gurudeva, what happens then if one commits an offence to a junior devotee? A neophyte devotee, what happens in that case?
Śrīla Gaura Govinda Svāmī Mahārāja: You see, we have an instruction, ‘one who is an ignorant fool, have mercy upon him.’ You see he doesn’t know all these things, so he is committing such a thing, such a blunder or mistake. So a Vaiṣṇava showers mercy upon him. One who is not an ignorant fool, who knows something, who has some knowledge, is an offender. Māyāvādī impersonalists who blaspheme Vaiṣṇavas, śāstra – there is a class of … an organisation named (inaudible), Brahma-kumārīs, like that, they don’t accept śāstra, so they come under this category; they are committing an offence, they are not ignorant fools, they are just presenting some different philosophy, all concocted, not based on śāstra – so one should avoid them. We should not listen to them, we should not stay in contact with them, and Vaiṣṇavas should avoid them. Those who are Vaiṣṇavas, devotees of Kṛṣṇa should not be friends with them. This is how to deal with certain persons.
Devotee 1: It seems that sometimes in our dealings as young devotees we fall into the habit of criticising another young devotee… criticising each other. Sometimes we fall into this habit. We were wondering if this also affects the chanting of the holy name.
Śrīla Gaura Govinda Svāmī Mahārāja: There are two things, one who is guru – a spiritual master must find fault for correction’s sake. He has that right, do you understand? Because he is guru, his business is to correct. They are committing some mistakes and blunders, offences. He is there to correct us, and teach us. Only he has that right. And those who are on his level, like gurus, as good as gurus, godbrothers of guru – known as guru-janas, they may also for correction’s sake. That is not criticism, that’s all good for us. But those who are of equal level, they sometimes play jokes… they mainly joke (amongst themselves). But others should not in any way. Those who are juniors have nothing to say to their seniors. No. Otherwise they will commit an offence.
Devotee 3: Regarding the first offence, you mentioned in class – blaspheming a Vaiṣṇava who has dedicated his life to the propagation of the holy name of the Lord. So sometimes we may see some senior devotees in leadership positions, and they might make some mistake, in our eyes apparently something is wrong, so we cannot say anything to them, should we just turn a blind eye –  should we mentally just ignore that?
Śrīla Gaura Govinda Svāmī Mahārāja: One thing is there, if you notice something that is contradictory to the Vaiṣṇava principles, Vaiṣṇava etiquette, behaviour… like that, we cannot ignore it. It is better to speak with one of his intimate friends and let him tell him. Or if you have access to him, you go there pay obeisances and with humility you may also tell… ‘I may be excused if I am committing some offence, it may be my ignorance, still I noticed something which gives me some pain in my heart, distress in my heart, so I have come to you to tell it. If it is my ignorance you may please excuse me or if it is a fact it is better, this is my request to you, please think it up seriously and correct yourself. It is also stated if guru does something (wrong) the disciple has the right to say also. Quoting authority, the disciple also has the right to tell his guru, ‘Guru Mahārāja, I am an ignorant fool but still I noticed such and such thing, will you please explain to me whether it is bona fide Vaiṣṇava etiquette. Or if it is not, please with my full obeisances to you, I pray to you please amend yourself.’ Confidentially tell him. That a disciple can also do. If in spite of all these things, the concerned Vaiṣṇava or guru doesn’t mend himself, then he can be rejected. This is our Vaiṣṇava etiquette.

Read Full Story at 



What do you think?

26 Points

Leave a Reply

Inconceivable, Not Illogical | Harmonist

Dispute Arises at Ladliji Temple Over Donation Box Money Extraction